I bought the punk corduroy last year for my daughter and absolutely loved them. This year's pink isn't as cute. My daughter is 9 and I bought the 10. The length is perfect but the width is way, way, way to big. I had to put the drawstring on the 9th hole for both sides. I guess if you have a hefty child then these will be great. I do take into consideration that my daughter is thin but these seem to be excessively large.